November 27, 2021


Only The Finest Women

Students suspended over long hair sue Texas school district for gender bias

Learners in the Magnolia Independent School District in suburban Houston have to adhere to various needs when it comes to their hairstyles. That includes preserving their locks “clean up, perfectly-groomed, and worn out of the eyes,” retaining “suitable cleanliness at all occasions” and getting a “all-natural hair shade.”

For males, the districtwide policy is even stricter: No beards or mustaches or very long sideburns hair won’t be able to be pinned up in a bun or held in a ponytail and its duration shouldn’t be lengthier than the base of the ear.

For at least six boys and a single university student assigned male at birth and who identifies as nonbinary, getting hair for a longer time than permitted has appear at a steep price tag this faculty yr: They’ve been suspended.

A federal lawsuit filed Thursday on behalf of those people pupils by the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas argues the punishment is biased and violates the two their constitutional legal rights and Title IX, the federal legislation that prohibits sex-dependent discrimination in schools. The pupils, who are identified by their initials, are looking for an injunction to halt enforcement of the plan.

“They have been denied classroom instruction, barred from extracurricular things to do, and compelled to be suspended and divided from their peers for properly over a month simply since these students do not conform to Magnolia ISD’s stereotypical notions of gender,” according to the fit in the U.S. District Court docket for the Southern District of Texas.

A university district spokeswoman did not quickly reply to a ask for for comment Thursday.

A study past 12 months by the ACLU of Texas found that just about 500 public faculty districts in the condition have some type of a boys-only hair-duration rule.

Hairstyles in colleges have develop into a level of contention throughout the state, specially in districts where by students of colour say they have been despatched household or advised to reduce their hair, which civil legal rights advocates argue is discriminatory. The concern acquired national interest once more last summer months when a federal judge in Texas blocked the Barbers Hill Independent College District, also close to Houston, from imposing a costume code coverage that prohibited a Black teenager from retaining his dreadlocks and would have also confined him to in-university suspension.

Brian Klosterboer, an ACLU staff attorney, mentioned the Magnolia University District appears to be having self-control to a amount that’s harmful to the students’ understanding. The learners, he added, are not academically troubled or would or else be viewed as challenge learners.

One particular of the boys is Latino and wears a lengthy ponytail, emulating his father and uncle with a hairstyle that is element of the family’s heritage, Klosterboer claimed. The boy, who is 9 decades old and in elementary faculty, was initially placed in in-school suspension for much more than a thirty day period, then forced into a disciplinary alternate education and learning method at another web site, in accordance to the fit. He is now homeschooled, though his sister, who attends the identical elementary faculty and has long hair, was not disciplined.

“I don’t think we’ve encountered what Magnolia is doing — that they are punishing a sizeable selection of pupils,” he mentioned. “A few college students have been pushed out of college. 3 ended up suspended and in in-faculty suspension for five weeks.”

Klosterboer reported the college students had been hunting forward to currently being again in the classroom for in-man or woman learning soon after a university yr of worries and disruptions all through the pandemic. He explained he’s not sure why the faculty district has “vigorously enforced” its hair plan, but that one of the plaintiffs has experienced long hair for the past 5 many years without the need of incurring disciplinary action.

Over the summertime, some college students and mothers and fathers voiced opposition to the policy for the duration of a school board conference. In a past statement, the school district explained it has had a dress code coverage “for several yrs.”

“The differentiated dress and grooming expectations do not violate Title IX and are involved in the scholar handbook each individual yr,” the assertion claimed. “Magnolia ISD’s approach to the dress code reflects the values of our local community at substantial.”

But Danielle Miller, whose 11-12 months-old baby, Tristan, is nonbinary and a plaintiff in the lawsuit, disagrees. The size of Tristan’s hair, which falls to the shoulders, and how they have on it does not diminish her child’s ability to master, Miller claimed, and their academics are accepting of it.

“Tristan feels powerful and self-assured with extensive hair,” Miller reported. “Tristan’s hair is constantly thoroughly clean and out of their deal with. I straighten it it each few of times for the reason that they like it that way. From time to time they like to have on a ponytail or berets.”

But administrators in the school district realize her child as getting male, Miller stated, which has led to Tristan’s suspension for nine days and they likely facial area additional punishment if they will not cut their hair. Miller included that she isn’t going to want to have to pull her boy or girl out of faculty.

The dispute more than suitable hairstyles boils down to this for Tristan, Miller mentioned: “‘It’s dumb, Mom. It can be just dumb that they will not accept, Mother.'”

This tale 1st appeared on