November 27, 2021


Only The Finest Women

Public loan guarantees and credit substitution

Carlo Altavilla, Andrew Ellul, Marco Pagano, Andrea Polo, Thomas Vlassopoulos 24 November 2021

Governments often supply personal loan assures to inspire lending by shouldering borrowers’ default possibility. These schemes can be specially helpful to sustain lender lending through economic crises, when default waves may perhaps propagate across debt chains interconnecting corporations, primary also normally viable corporations to be liquidated. Financial loan promise programmes may possibly deliver the demanded backstop, insofar as transferring default hazard to the government encourages banking institutions to raise lending, even to challenging-hit firms. They may possibly also be a faster and extra efficient way to allocate general public guidance to firms than direct federal government funding, as usually banks have screening technologies and established associations that endow them with improved info than the governing administration about the high quality of each individual business (Philippon 2021). This clarifies why numerous nations around the world released large mortgage warranty techniques to provide crisis lending to corporations before long right after the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic (Schivardi and Romano 2020, Demmou and Franco 2021).

A crucial issue, nevertheless, is no matter if these financial loan ensures translate into one particular-for-just one will increase in bank lending, or are partially utilized to repay pre-current non-certain loans? And, if this kind of credit history substitution takes place, for which forms of firms and banking institutions does it tend to happen? The media have frequently voiced the concern that loan ensures may perhaps stop up benefiting banks extra than companies strike by the pandemic shock. For instance, on 4 July 2021 the Financial Instances drew awareness to Greensill Bank AG utilizing condition-backed loans from European governments to lessen its exposure to distressed organizations owned by metal magnate Sanjeev Gupta. 

In a new paper (Altavilla et al. 2021), we use a novel euro space credit rating sign up dataset, Anacredit, to investigate exactly no matter whether the community mortgage promise schemes launched at the onset of the pandemic led to substitution of non-confirmed with assured credit history fairly than absolutely introducing to the offer of lending. This behaviour is explained by Blanchard et al. (2020) as follows: “The major danger is the transfer of pre-existing exposures. A lender with an exposure to a firm could talk to it to use the confirmed personal debt to repay its current loans. This would be a transfer of threat to the condition.” Without a doubt, Figure 1 reveals that before long immediately after the period when loan guarantee schemes have been launched in the euro location to counter the pandemic, mixture net lending grew less than a person-for-one particular with the expansion of confirmed financial loans. However, this kind of region-stage info can barely be noticed as proof of substitution at the lender-agency degree. This is why we look into the challenge of credit rating substitution by employing granular company-bank-degree info.

Figure 1 Ensure loans and net lending

Note: This figure reveals the romance among the choose-up of confirmed loans and internet personal loan flows at a country level about the time period April to August 2020. Each individual blue dot refers to a state in the euro spot. 

Credit score substitution may well originate from banks’ credit history source guidelines: financial institutions can need companies to (at minimum partly) use certain personal debt to repay existing loans, so as to cut down their publicity towards them. Evidently, banking companies have the biggest incentive to engage in this sort of behaviour vis-à-vis their riskiest shoppers. But substitution may perhaps also be triggered by corporations wishing to renegotiate pre-existing liabilities at decrease interest prices, by changing them with publicly assured debt. This can be the scenario for viable and liquid companies, which would not experience significant difficulties to attain credit rating with no the help of the warranty programme. 

A single way to assist disentangle whether or not any credit score substitution is taking spot due to lender-driven, instead than organization-pushed, motives is to investigate the features of creditors and debtors noticed in the facts. For example, substitution is a lot more possible to be bank-driven for risky companies with superior liquidity wants, and to be firm-pushed in the case of solvent corporations with reduced liquidity requirements. In the previous situation, substitution would mirror the stringency of banks’ credit score source, although in the latter it would mirror firms’ small demand from customers for credit. 

The eligibility policies that identify the allocation of credit rating assures are probable to impact the extent of substitution. To illustrate this stage, Figure 2 demonstrates a hypothetical distribution of corporations according to their credit high-quality, that is, an index capturing both equally solvency and liquidity. Excluding the riskiest companies from the financial loan assurance programme quantities to slicing off the left tail of the distribution from the populace of beneficiaries, and thus should really restrict the extent of lender-driven substitution. Conversely, discriminating from firms spared by the pandemic shock and thus even now solvent and liquid ought to minimize off the ideal tail of the distribution, and thus limit the extent of agency-pushed substitution. European policymakers show up to have been knowledgeable of this problem in laying out eligibility tips for bank loan assure programmes.

Figure 2 Publicly confirmed loans: Firm eligibility and credit score substitution 

Notice: This determine reveals how the choice of firms obtaining guaranteed financial loans might have an effect on the substitution of non-assured credit rating with assured credit. Companies are rated by increasing solvency and liquidity. 

Empirically, we discover that guaranteed financial loans were overwhelmingly allocated to firms that are modest and functioning in the most heavily impacted industries, but not to corporations that were already in or near to distress ahead of the pandemic, in line with the EU Commission pointers. Noticed from this point of view, the guaranteed credit rating programmes in the euro place have been thriving in channelling substantially-necessary credit rating to firms in the most seriously strike industries, whilst leveraging banks’ information to display screen out the worst threats. This result also implies that the true selection of plan beneficiaries is possible to have contained the extent of substitution. We also discover that corporations ended up far more very likely to acquire confirmed credit score from the most significant and most solid banking companies, confirming the importance of healthy stability sheets as a vital system in the provision of liquidity at situations of anxiety. 

We then investigate whether or not the assured financial loans constituted new lending, or in its place substitution transpired. We estimate the agency-level substitution of pre-current credit linked with an raise in confirmed lending, i.e. how substantially pre-current loans to a specified company drop from February 2020 to August 2020 for an added euro of guaranteed financial loans. At organization level, we come across that confirmed financial loans resulted in a moderate diploma of substitution. Curiously, substitution is (a) bigger in companies that are smaller, ex ante riskier (credit history risk remaining measured by the magnitude of pre-disaster arrears), and working in sectors that expert a larger fall in value-included for the duration of the pandemic and (b) larger for corporations borrowing from extra sound banks, i.e. larger sized, additional capitalised financial institutions with decrease NPLs. Outcomes are broadly regular throughout the premier four euro region nations, regardless of some distinctions in the layout of national promise schemes. On the whole, the proof implies that, to get hold of new guaranteed credit, risky corporations ended up required to renegotiate some of their pre-current financial loans.

The granularity of our facts permits us to assess a firm’s borrowing from the bank that prolonged a assured mortgage to it to that from other banking companies that experienced a lending connection with the similar firm. This lets us to construct a counterfactual for that firm’s lender borrowing in the absence of ensures and for that reason to a lot more properly pin down substitution. We uncover that substitution occurs from the behaviour of the financial institutions extending assured financial loans: banks giving guaranteed financial loans reduce pre-current credit score up to 36% extra than other banking companies lending to the same business. Determine 3 illustrates how credit history substitution may differ based on business, bank and agency-financial institution properties. As the figure reveals, in-firm estimates verify that credit score substitution was biggest for guaranteed funding granted to riskier and more compact companies running in a lot more afflicted sectors, and borrowing from bigger and more robust banks, whilst banking associations attenuated credit rating substitution.

Determine 3 Dissimilarities in credit rating substitution across companies and banking institutions

Notes: This determine reports the magnitude of the coefficients linked with interactions amongst a dummy variable (equivalent to 1 if the bank is giving the guaranteed bank loan and if not) and several firm, bank and company-bank traits, in share points. Just about every coefficient is multiplied by one particular conventional deviation of the variable in the sample to gauge the financial importance of the estimated effects. The packing containers point out the 90% confidence interval linked with the corresponding coefficient and the whiskers the 95% self-assurance interval. “Industry worth additional growth” is made use of as a proxy for the extent to which the sector was impacted by the crisis. “Bank-Business relationship” is measured by the share of the lender in the firm’s whole bank credit rating exposure. The reduction in pre-present non-assured exposure by the lender supplying the guaranteed mortgage is bigger for: corporations operating in sectors that professional a larger sized drop in price-extra in the course of the pandemic, lesser companies, ex-ante riskier companies, greater banks, banks with a reduced proportion of NPLs, weaker business-financial institution associations.

Over-all, our success clearly show that in the euro region, federal government ensures contributed to the continued extension of credit score to comparatively creditworthy firms hit by the pandemic, but also benefited the equilibrium sheet of banks to some extent. Though mortgage promise programmes were being created to mitigate it, a average sum of credit substitution did come about, and for that reason some loan assures transferred pre-present credit score risk from banking institutions to taxpayers. 

Even so, this does not always show a failure of the public credit score schemes, for a few good reasons. 1st, absent these schemes, banking companies could have diminished their pre-existing credit score exposures even a lot more, possibly producing default waves that may possibly have crippled even if not practical companies. Next, to the extent that banking institutions utilised this kind of strategies to de-danger their equilibrium sheets, they may possibly have preserved their lending potential to much better confront the publish-pandemic restoration period of time: consequently, this implicit financial institution recapitalisation may minimize the risk of a cliff-result credit score crunch when loan assure strategies and other guidance packages are terminated (Laeven et al. 2020, Beck et al. 2021). Third, insofar as substitution moderated lending to the riskiest companies, these should really exit the pandemic with lessen leverage, therefore much less debt overhang (Brunnermeier and Krishnamurthy 2020, Gobbi et al. 2020), than in a counterfactual planet wherever no substitution happened.


Altavilla, C, A Ellul, M Pagano, A Polo and T Vlassopoulos (2021), “Loan Ensures, Financial institution Lending and Credit Possibility Reallocation”, CEPR Dialogue Paper No. 16727.

Antill, S, and C Clayton (2021), “Crisis Interventions in Company Insolvency,” unpublished, February.

Beck, T, E Carletti, and B Bruno (2021), “Unwinding COVID aid steps for banks”,, 17 March.

Blanchard, O, T Philippon and J Pisani-Ferry (2020), “A New Plan Toolkit Is Desired as Countries Exit COVID-19 Lockdowns,” Bruegel Plan Contribution no. 12.

Brunnermeier, M and A Krishnamurthy (2020) “Corporate Financial debt Overhang and Credit score Plan,” Brookings Papers on Financial Action, Summer season: 447-488.

Demmou, L and G Franco (2021), “From hibernation to reallocation: mortgage guarantees and their implications for write-up-COVID-19 productivity”,, 14 November.

Glode, V, and C C Opp (2021), “Private Renegotiations and Federal government Interventions in Credit card debt Chains,” SSRN Doing work Paper No. 3667071.

Gobbi, G, F Palazzo, and A Segura (2020), “Unintended results of loan ensures all through the Covid-19 crisis”,, 15 April.

Laeven, L, G Schepens, and I Schnabel (2020), “Zombification in Europe in times of pandemic”,, 11 October.

Philippon, T (2021), “Efficient Systems to Help Businesses All through and Following Lockdowns,” The Evaluation of Company Finance Experiments 10: 188-203.

Schivardi, F, and G Romano (2020), “Liquidity crisis: Maintaining corporations afloat all through Covid-19”,, 18 July.