December 5, 2021


Only The Finest Women

Doctor fails to stop investigation into Covid-19 misinformation videos

Samantha Bailey, whose videos have drawn complaints to the Medical Council about Covid misinformation. (File photo)

Stacy Squires/Things

Samantha Bailey, whose films have drawn complaints to the Health care Council about Covid misinformation. (File picture)

A doctor submitting Covid-19 misinformation films has shed a Higher Court docket bid to halt further investigation by the Health care Council into her functions.

Samantha Bailey​,​ who is recognized for appearing on TV’s The Look at Up and her have YouTube channel, is a health-related medical professional, but does not display on the Professional medical Council website as having a practising certificate.

A number of her videos are no more time accessible on YouTube.

She had requested Justice Matthew Palmer​ in the Large Courtroom at Wellington to stay all proceedings and to halt the council from getting even further action until finally a full hearing into the council’s final decision-building process.

Study Much more:
* Choose requested to end investigation into Covid misinformation video clips
* Taranaki physician below investigation right after getting accused of spreading misinformation about Covid-19
* The physicians seeking to hijack New Zealand’s Covid-19 vaccination rollout
* 13 medical professionals underneath investigation right after issues about spread of Covid-19 misinformation
* Covid-19: ‘Multiple complaints’ above anti-vaccine medical practitioners

Justice Palmer said there had been 15 notifications or problems about Bailey’s movies from, eight customers of the general public four registered medical practitioners in New Zealand one retired New Zealand physician in the United Kingdom and two health-related practitioners in the United Kingdom.


Confirmation bias is a hardwired component of human psychology that can make us significantly susceptible to on the net misinformation and disinformation.

He mentioned her YouTube channel experienced a lot more than 300,000 subscribers and of the videos at situation, there had been four or 5 however offered.

The Professional medical Council had referred Bailey’s perform to a Professional Carry out Committee above 4 difficulties.

They were the situation of her figuring out herself as a health care provider, irrespective of whether she was practising exterior her scope of practise, her adherence to good health care exercise and whether or not she is practising without having a practising certification.

Justice Matthew Palmer has allowed a Medical Council to continue investigating whether Samantha Bailey was practising medicine when she posted Covid-19 misinformation videos. (file photo)

Dean Kozanic/Stuff

Justice Matthew Palmer has allowed a Health care Council to carry on investigating whether Samantha Bailey was practising drugs when she posted Covid-19 misinformation movies. (file photo)

He mentioned Bailey was to ask the court to critique the council’s determination to investigate. She would argue that publishing movies was not the practise of drugs and any disciplinary motion would infringe on her ideal to liberty of speech. That listening to would be subsequent yr.

He explained she had now questioned the courtroom to remain the proceedings and prohibit the council from having further more action right until that hearing.

Her lawyer, Rodney Harrison QC,​ said the queries right before the committee were either straight underpinned or noticeably affected by no matter whether she was practising drugs by putting up the video clips and it was not lawful for it to embark on the investigation or to breach her freedom of speech.

The council’s lawyer, Simon Mount QC, stated delaying the investigation would be contrary to the public curiosity.

Justice Palmer stated there was general public curiosity in soundly-dependent health care practitioner disciplinary procedures proceeding.

“And there is distinctive community fascination in not delaying an result of referring the subject matter make a difference of the investigation to the law enforcement,” he claimed.

He stated Bailey would be specified a prospect to react to the committee.

The disciplinary process should be allowed to carry on in the interests of justice, Justice Palmer reported.

Resource url